Do freelancing job sites work?

You might have seen some outsourcing websites where freelancers can register, bid, and apply for jobs posted up by companies and individuals around the world. People Per Hour, 3desk, Fiverr, Guru, oDesk and Elance are just a few of those sites but there are a ton out there if you look. But do these types of websites actually lead to paid work?

My experience of freelancing job sites

Personally I’ve never found a Virtual Assistant who has secured decent work from a freelancing job site but that’s not to say that some people don’t or won’t. I know a Digital Animator who gets clients from a specialist niche job site, but I think the problem with the more mainstream sites is there’s so many generalists competing against each other and you’d have to spend so much time writing proposals and bidding, you’d never get any other work done.

I once registered on a few sites but didn’t get any work from them. I also felt a bit like I was at a cattle market trying to prove my worth to someone and it felt not unlike a “pick me, pick me!!” situation if I’m honest.


Cheap as chips and paying peanuts

If you want to go nowhere follow the crowdFrankly I think a lot of people who post jobs on freelancing job sites are looking for someone cheap. They know they can hire someone willing to undercut everyone else or someone living in a country with a lower cost of living who can afford to do the job for half the price of everyone else – and this leaves you out of the running unless you’re willing to undervalue and underprice what you do.

And you’re not about to do that are you?

I’m not against offshore outsourcing (everyone needs to make a living) but if a business hires a freelancer in their own country they’re contributing to the economy and paying the going rate for expert assistance. Plus they can potentially build a stronger working relationship with that person as they’re in the same time zone and can even meet.

I think it’s much better to pitch yourself above the plethora of humdrum freelancers, set yourself up as a specialist and go after clients you want to work with rather than sitting around hoping to get picked and taking part in a demeaning race to the bottom.

Conclusion and resources

My advice is to give freelancing job sites a go as you’ve got nothing to lose but, like all your marketing efforts, if they don’t work for you then stop wasting your time and try something else.

  • There’s a good article called The Dangers of Elance, oDesk and Other Freelancer Marketplaces over on the Freelance Advisor website.

I’d love to hear your experiences of freelancing job sites – have you tried them and did they led to quality work?

13 Comments

Kelley H

I had a horrible experience with Elance. I bid on and won a couple of jobs, worked very hard and did good work. My first job, I did excellent work but because the client would not verify themselves with the hours tracker software my hours could not be verified. My invoice was rejected. I was ripped off to the tune of about $700 USD (about $1000 CAD). The second job I won, same thing. The client simply would not verify himself. I didn’t do any of the work but much time was wasted still. There are many ways clients can take advantage of newbies on the site and get a lot of work done for free.

Reply
Joanne Munro

Hi Kelley – that sounds AWFUL! What a nightmare and that is such a lot of money to lose. I’ve never used Elance myself so it’s really interesting hearing from people who have. Your report doesn’t make me want to go near it to be honest…

Reply
Andreea

i’m a beginner in this field but i like it very much. I have more than 6 years experience as an markting/ manager/ personal assistant and I’m eager to become a successful virtual assistant. I placed lots of proposals on freelancing job sites but no response. Where should i start from? How can I put myself on the market and get noticed? Thank you for the amazing job that you do helping hundreds of youngsters to find their way!

Reply
Joanne Munro

Thank you for your comment Andreea. I suggest a combination of reading my post on 23 ways to market your business and buying my guide on how to get clients. It outlines the only way I use to get clients – plus, you have marketing experience so just think of yourself as the product! Most of the people who read my site and who become VAs are actually women aged 30+ so not just youngsters. To be a good VA you have to be resourceful and to communicate well. Where there’s a will, there’s a way! x

Reply
emma

I signed up to one of these sites – but didn’t find it very effective for the amount you were paid per hour. I don’t think you can beat finding your own clients and coming to a ongoing business relationship where you build up a rapport with them.

Reply
Suzanne

I joined Time Etc and although the work was coming in, if you were not quick enough to accept the task then another VA got it. I have had no work from them for 2 months, due to them saying I have negative customer feedback but I have never seen the feedback. I have only done 3 tasks in 3 months!!!!!!

Reply
Joanne Munro

Thank you for taking the time to comment Suzanne. I’ve never used sites such as these but they had always seemed a waste of time – if they were that good then surely all the VAs would be using them! I think working for sites like these also make you a bit of an online temp – at the mercy of another (but invisible) boss. I’ve always thought it better to go out and get your own clients and be recognised for the work you do – and paid well for it! Thanks for sharing your experience Suzanne. x

Reply
Sharon Lewis

I registered with a few too and had a response from a proposal saying other VA’s were cheaper, even though I had reduced my fee within the proposal. I had another that kept emailing me making appointments to ring me in response to another proposal – and he never rang – just kept emailing me, apologising and making new appointments – he still never rang. So, I agree, try it – but try to put more effort in elsewhere, where the quality of the Client is a little superior.

Reply
Nicolle French

Hi guys I signed up to a few of these sites when first starting out but soon found that the simply drained my energy and took my focus away from creating great work to writing bids all day. For some of them if you don’t accept a job in super speedy time (and by this I mean 5 mins or less) you lose out which is not what I personallyfeel is a great start to a client/freelance brief. I soon stepped away from this model as if clients want the cheapest proposal they will shop around and have no loyalty to your brand.

Reply
Sabra Way

I tried Elance for a while and even paid for a few extras on the site. I found the overall quality of the offered jobs to be poor. Lots of writing crap blog posts – almost link bait – for pennies. When I did bid on work I have the same feeling as Joanne described in the post. Pick me, Pick me! I got all the way to a Skype interview for one potential client where my skill set (nutritional supplement knowledge) was essential. I gave a fair quote and so be honest, lowered my rate a bit, becasue I wanted the work and becasue I knew that those bids got more work. In the end the potential client exclaimed, ‘Oh that is more than double what I want pay!’ In my opinion the bidding process takes too much time for little or no reward.

Reply
Joanne Munro

I agree; you’ll never be the cheapest and you wouldn’t want to be. Thank you so much for your comment and taking time out to contribute to the site, it’s really appreciated. x

Reply
Cleo- aka

I joined ” Upworks”, sent numerous proposal and they all were people trying to get my personal information from all over the world. Luckily I decided to contact the companies they said they represented and was told they were all scams, not one was real. One person even presented himself as a pastor of a very large Non-profit organization.
I accepted a job offer, due to having family responsibilities and am building my business part time. I now use contacts from my network events.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *